Shin Splints or a Stress Fracture? How to Decipher Your Leg Pain

Nov 16, 2026
Shin Splints or a Stress Fracture? How to Decipher Your Leg Pain
If you’re a runner, aches and pains are common. When it comes to nagging lower-leg pain, shin splints and stress fractures are both common culprits, and we review both here. Plus, next steps moving forward.

An active life is incredibly important for optimizing your physical and mental health, and you subscribe to this completely. Whether you’re a daily runner or you enjoy other active pursuits, the unfortunate reality is that sports injuries and wear-and-tear are part of the active lifestyle.

Two common examples are shin splints, which affect up to 20% of runners, and stress fractures, which account for 20% of sports injuries.

If you’re dealing with pain in your lower leg(s) that’s sidelining you from your favorite pursuits, the multidisciplinary team at Michigan Avenue Primary Care discusses both shin splints and stress fractures here. While the two are very similar, they differ, as we’ll cover below.

Shin splints at a glance

Let’s start with shin splints, which, as we mentioned, are among the most common exercise-related injuries.

Also called medial tibial stress syndrome, shin splints are caused by inflammation in the muscles, tendons, and bone tissue of your tibia, one of your shin bones.

This painful inflammation most often develops from overuse, as well as:

  • Starting a running program
  • Changing your running frequency, duration, or intensity

For example, if you ramp up your activity too quickly, you can develop shin splints. Or, if you change the terrain you run on and transition from flat to hilly too suddenly, you can also develop shin splints.

Stress fractures in your shins

Now let’s briefly describe stress fractures in your shins. In most cases, these hairline fractures develop in the larger of your two shin bones — your tibia — and they mostly develop from overuse.

Stress fractures in your shin develop gradually — it starts as pressure on the bone that damages the hard tissue. If you don’t rest your weakened bones and, instead, continue to remain active, stress fractures can develop.

Signs of shin splints and stress fractures

When it comes to deciphering between stress fractures and shin splints, this can be tricky because both conditions share many of the same symptoms.

One primary way to differentiate the two is this: With shin splints, the pain in your lower legs flares when you run but typically dies down when you’re less active. This pain can be sharp or a dull throbbing.

With stress fractures, the damage is cumulative, and the pain builds over time and with use, so you can end up dealing with leg pain anytime you put weight on your feet. In other words, even walking can cause some pain.

Another distinction is that shin splints cause more all-over pain, while stress fractures tend to be more localized around the hairline break. Either condition can cause tenderness in your shins.

Getting back to pain-free running

The best way to determine what’s behind your lower leg pain is to see us for an evaluation, and the sooner you come in, the sooner you can start healing.

The good news is that whatever we find — shin splints or a stress fracture — treatment is much the same and involves:

  • Rest
  • Anti-inflammatory medications
  • Activity modification 
  • Orthotics
  • Compression
  • Cross training
  • Physical therapy

Once we give you the green light, you can start adding activity as you heal, usually about 10% per week, so you can rebuild slowly and prevent re-injury.

For expert care for any lower leg injury, please don’t hesitate to contact our Chicago clinic today, conveniently located in The Loop, to schedule an appointment.